Paolo Bacigalupi – Ship Breaker

Author: Paolo Bacigalupi
Title: Ship Breaker
Published: May 2010
Publisher: Little, Brown
Length: 323 pages
Genre: Dystopian scifi
Target age: Young adult
Why I picked it up: Hank Green
Rating: 3.5 stars

Buy: Chapters | Barnes and Noble | Check your local bookstore!

I enjoyed Ship Breaker much more than Marcus of Umbria. It has been a very long time since I’ve blown through a fiction book so quickly. Young adult novels may be below my ‘reading level’ but I can still enjoy a good one (and when would I ever read the bad ones? ;P). YA novels are usually much better written than so-called ‘adult fiction’ – once I find a good YA novel, it leaves more of an imprint on me than anything else does. I can enjoy it immensely and learn from it for my own writing.

Now that I’ve said all that about YA, I need to backtrack a bit…Ship Breaker was a good book but not one of the ones that has made a lasting impact on me. It was an enjoyable read, brought up some good ideas, had a few tense moments, but the characters didn’t make an emotional impact on me. That’s okay. Not every novel has to be made of John Green moments.

One of the things I liked best about this book was that it presented certain ideas well that I feel are usually presented awkwardly (like this sentence :P). One of the issues the book tackles is the morals of protecting the environment over making money (the novel is set in ‘Orleans’ where everything has been destroyed by impossibly strong hurricanes) and it actually presents both sides well, as in: you can see why somebody might take the money over the environment, which I usually have a hard time understanding. Another issue the book handles nicely is that of the morals of killing. Usually I find that after a character’s ‘first kill’ they’re overcome with guilt to an extreme that’s a little unbelievable. That didn’t happen as much in this book; it felt more natural.

A few more thoughts…The book is an action/adventure and that is exactly what it feels like. It’s not tickly  – emotional at all. I didn’t form any attachments to the characters, but they felt fairly well-developed and unique. No hero stereotypes here.The ending was a little abrupt, I like a fuller ending but it does wrap up the story. All in all, Ship Breakers was a fun and thoughtful read. I’d probably recommend it if you’re looking for something fast paced and gritty but enjoyable.

Justine van der Leun – Marcus of Umbria

  
Author: Justine van der Leun
Title: Marcus of Umbria
Published: June 2010
Publisher: Rodale Books
Length: 224 pages
Genre: Travel memoir
Target age: Adult
Why I picked it up: Sounded like light summer reading (it took awhile for the hold to come in)
Rating: 1 star
Buy: Chapters | Barnes and Noble | Check your local bookstore!

It’s been a long time since I’ve finished a book that left me feeling so frustrated and unsatisfied. Usually I can tell within the first 20 pages or so whether I’m going to enjoy a book or not, but I decided to stick it out with this one. Forgive me now while I rant about the shortcomings of this book.

This book was dreary, dull, negative. The author had nothing positive to say about her travels. The entire memoir consists of her complaining about everything she encounters within the culture she chose to place herself in. She finds it appalling that people treat dogs as work animals and not as companions. I was thoroughly disgusted at some of the comments she made. There was one statement (on page 136) that made me lose whatever hope I had that the author was going to redeem herself.  While complaining about how the locals never throw food out, the author says:

I’d seen her use brown bananas to bake a fluffy breakfast loaf.

Well, yeah, what the hell do you think breakfast loaf is made with? (Maybe that seems a little like overreacting, but after 136 pages of the author’s petty whining I couldn’t take it any more). Granted, some of the things that bother her are valid, but for the most it’s just her bitching about how she hates life in the Italian country. And yet she chooses to live there for months with a man she admits she’s not in love with.

That’s the other thing that was frustrating. The book is advertised as ‘What an Italian dog taught an American girl about love’, but the dog is mentioned on maybe 40 pages (and that sounds a bit generous). Barely at all. I expected the entire book to be about the author and her loving adventures with her dog but frankly, the dog could have been removed from the book and it would have been the same. Every now and then, the author mentions that she loves her dog and not her boyfriend, but you never see that or feel it. It’s like she just threw the dog in there so she could make a nice sounding book about it.

You never feel like you’re getting the whole story. You don’t feel sorry for her and her boyfriend (a page or two says ‘Yeah, we eventually realized it wasn’t going to work out but I stuck around anyhow), you don’t feel the love for the dog. When I finished this book, I was immensely to relieved to not have to read any more of the author’s shallow and selfish opinions.

Right, so that all sounds a little a harsh. As annoyed with the author as I was, I still managed to finish the book. It was not at all enjoyable, but I managed. I think I would feel a lot better about the whole thing if it wasn’t marketed as dog love story. Perhaps a better subtitle would be ‘Why I Hate Country Hicks of Italy’ (but I guess that wouldn’t sell as well…).

Ernest Hemingway – A Moveable Feast

 Author: Ernest Hemingway

Title: A Moveable Feast
Published: December 1964
Publisher: Scribners (USA)
Length: 211 pages
Genre: Memoir
Target age: Adult
Why I picked it up: About Paris in the 1920s, starting to read books by the Lost Generation 
Rating: 4 stars
Buy: Chapters | Barnes and Noble | Check your local bookstore!

[A quick note on the edition I’m reading: I’ve got a first edition out from the library (the cover is the same as the image I posted above). I intend to buy this book, but I’ll probably prowl some used bookstores trying to find the copy I want.]

Will update this post on Monday! Terribly sorry for posting something half written 🙁 I’m done the book, I just haven’t the time to reflect right now, unfortunately.

***

This book was my first foray into reading something by such a great and esteemed author. I’m very much a reader of the modern novel, but I have been interested in getting into the ‘greats’ such as Hemingway and Fitzgerald and Kerouac and all the others from different eras. Because of my interest in the subject matter, I decided A Moveable Feast was as good as any a place to start.

I very much enjoyed this book, even if it isn’t very representative of Hemingway’s actual ‘literature.’ I love his crisp writing style, which I’ve gathered is something he’s well-known for (don’t look at me that way! I have nobody to teach me about these things, I’m learning as I go).

Naomi Klein – The Shock Doctrine

Author: Naomi Klein
Title: The Shock Doctrine
Published: September 2007
Publisher: Knopf Canada
Length: 672 pages
Genre: Non-fiction, economics
Target age: Adult
Why I picked it up: Shopping spree at Chapters one day
Buy: Chapters | Barnes and Noble | Check your local bookstore!

This a pretty hefty book so I haven’t finished it yet. That being said, I’ve also owned the book for five months and should probably get around to finishing it…

Since I’ve owned the book for so long and haven’t read it yet, I could forgive you for thinking it’s not worth reading. That would be a false belief. I’ve learnt so much from this book and I’m only on page 137.n(I haven’t had a lot of time for reading since school started up, which is why I’m posting this when I’ve only read a bit, but I’ll make another post when I finish the book).

When the juntas set out to defy Allende’s prophecy and pull up socialism by its roots, it was a declaration of war against this entire culture.

The first part of this book is mainly about US intervention in Chile and the 1973 coup, as well as what was happening in other parts of South America at the time. These are topics I have absolutely no knowledge about: the reading so far has been fascinating to me. I’ve gasped, had to stop and felt ashamed of my ignorance while reading. The whole subject is well explained and I feel like it actually is preparing me for the rest of the book, which focuses on the shock doctrine being used in Iraq, Afghanistan, etc. I look forward to rest of the book and the things I’ll learn. Things I probably would rather not know about, but those are the things you need to hear the most, right? I think this will be a very informative book…(now I’m interested in what I’ll say after I’ve actually read the whole thing ;P).

Eoin Colfer – Artemis Fowl: The Atlantis Complex

Author: Eoin Colfer
Series: Artemis Fowl
Title: The Atlantis Complex
Published: August 2010
Publisher: Hyperion
Length: 432 pages
Genre: Modern fantasy
Target age: Preteen
Why I picked it up: Been reading the series since grade five
Rating: 1.5 stars

Buy: Chapters | Barnes and Noble | Check your local bookstore!

After the sixth book in the series, The Time Paradox, was released, I don’t know why, but I doubted that another book would be released. Well, surprises, surprises! Usually I’m on top of these things, but I only knew this book existed once I saw it stores. I bought it immediately but didn’t devour it immediately which might tell you something about the quality of the book.

I think the best volumes of the series were 1-4. Volumes 5 and 6 were fine, but not quite as good as the previous four. As for The Atlantis Complex, I can think of a few terms and phrases to describe it (in comparison to the other books in the series): Dull. Jokes that aren’t funny. Not up to standards. Lacking in character and plot. Disappointing. If the next book (to be the final) is on the same level as this one, I will be more than a little upset.

The main issue with this book is that the plot and characters are greatly lacking and those are the two things I love most about the Artemis Fowl series. There was no suspense, no clever twists and turns. The idea of Atlantis Complex was an intriguing one but it was executed poorly (Orion = one of the worsts ideas in the book). I didn’t feel as connected to the characters. They didn’t make me laugh, smile or cry with their weak dialogue. The whole book just fell flat: It felt like a poorly written fanfiction.

MINOR SPOILERS AHEAD

HOWEVER! Not all was terrible. I still enjoyed reading a new Artemis adventure, even if it was not nearly as good. If you’re a fan you’ll make it through this volume, just perhaps not as urgently as the other books. The villain was unexpected. (To people disappointed with the lack of Opal: Don’t you know she only shows up in every second book? ;P Save Artemis’ final battle for her!) Towards the end of the book, Artemis says something that I think redeems the novel, if only a little bit:

“This adventure was different, Holly. Usually someone wins, and we are better off at the end. But this time so many people died – innocents -and no one has benefited.”

I think that quote summarizes the book quite well. The adventure was different, and no one benefited.