35 Middle Grade Fantasy Faves [Wyrd & Wonder]

Posted 22 May 2020 in list /12 Comments

Preamble

Today’s post features my favourite middle grade fantasy books. I chose titles that are personal faves. These books were all 4+ star reads for me. A list of ‘best middle grade fantasy’ would look a little different. These books represent what I think of when I hear fantasy. For me, fantasy features happenings that could never occur in our world. Fantasy roots itself in imagination and magic. (I am not the person to explain the difference between fantasy and science fiction, but my view is that science fiction has more basis in real possibilities and technology.) This post is part of Wyrd & Wonder, a month long celebration of the fantastic (Flaming phoenix by Sujono Sujono).


Overview

2020 – 2017

🏞️ A Wish in the Dark (2020)
πŸ‘» Ghost Squad (2020)
πŸ‘» The Ghost Collector (2019)
πŸ‘» A Sprinkle of Spirits (2019)
πŸ‘» Just South of Home (2019)
🐲 Malamander (2019)
🐲 Scary Stories for Young Foxes (2019)
🏞️ Silver Batal and the Water Dragon Races (2019)
🏞️ Snared: Escape to the Above (2019)
🏞️ Thisby Thestoop and the Black Mountain (2018)
🐲 Dragons in a Bag (2018)
🌍 The Book of Boy (2018)
🏞️ The Stone Girl’s Story (2018)
πŸ‘» Spirit Hunters (2017)
πŸ‘» A Properly Unhaunted Place (2017)
🏞️ The Dragon with a Chocolate Heart (2017)
🏞️ The Trials of Morrigan Crow (2017)

2016 – 1994

🏞️ The Girl Who Drank the Moon (2016)
🏞️ When the Sea Turned to Silver (2016)
🌍 The Inquisitor’s Tale (2016)
🧚🏼 The Girl Who Raced Fairyland All the Way Home (2016)
πŸ’€ The Nest (2015)
πŸ’€ Hoodoo (2015)
πŸ’€ The Jumbies (2015)
πŸ‘» The Swallow (2014)
πŸ’€ Cuckoo Song (2014)
🌍 Splendors and Glooms (2012)
🏞️ Tuesdays at the Castle (2011)
πŸ’€ A Monster Calls (2011)
πŸ’€ Everlost (2006)
πŸ’€ Coraline (2002)
🧚🏼 Artemis Fowl (2001)
🐲 The Sight (2001)
🧚🏼 The Lost Flower Children (1999)
🏞️ Into the Land of the Unicorns (1994)


Category Guide

The six emojis in the above list correspond to six categories into which I’ve grouped the books. These categories aren’t genres. I just lumped them together by what I consider their broadest defining feature. πŸ˜›

  • 🏞️ Secondary World (11 books)
    • Books outside this category take place in or are connected to the real world (i.e. portal fantasy).
  • πŸ‘» Ghosts (7 books)
  • πŸ’€ Creepy (7 books)
    • Books that have a creepy/dark/unsettling atmosphere that’s not attributed to ghosts. A few titles don’t fit here perfectly but they were close enough.
  • 🐲 Creatures (4 books)
    • The main attraction of these books is mythical creatures or anthropomorphized animals.
  • 🧚🏼 Fairies (3 books)
  • 🌍 Historical (3 books)
    • The real world historical setting is integral to the story being told. Two of the books in this category might be described as religious fantasy. For example, the fantastical elements are portrayed as miracles of a certain religion. This type of fantasy intrigued me so much I wrote a paper on it for my master’s degree, lol (“Blurring the Line between Speculative and Historical Fiction: Representations of Christianity in Post-Medieval Historical Novels for Children”).

Titles link to my reviews were applicable. #ownvoices identifications are what the author has publicly identified as, as far as I could find.


🏞️ Secondary World

A Wish in the Dark by Christina Soontornvat
Thai analogue world
Magic fuelled light orbs
Monk mentor
Les Mis retelling
#ownvoices (Asian-American)

Silver Batal and the Water Dragon Races by K.D. Halbrook
Arab-inspired world
Desert girl bonds with rare water dragon
Action/adventure
#ownvoices (Lebanese-American)

Snared: Escape to the Above by Adam Jay Epstein
Master of dungeon traps
Ragtag band of adventures
Offbeat characters and events
Defeat the evil lord

Thisby Thestoop and the Black Mountain by Zac Gorman
Caretaker of dungeon critters
Glowing slime sidekick
Dry humour
Unexpected friendship

The Stone Girl’s Story by Sarah Beth Durst
Living stone sculptures
World gradually revealed
Allegory about independence
Mostly peaceful and pleasant

The Dragon with the Chocolate Heart by Sarah Stephanie Burgis
Western Europe analogue world (I think)
Dragon transformed
Chocolatier’s apprentice
Royals and elitism
Unique protagonist

Nevermoor: The Trials of Morrigan Crow by Jessica Townsend
Feared chosen one
Secret city
Magical trials
Prestigious organization
Legit comp for Harry Potter

The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill
Caring grown ups
Looming volcano
Creative magic system
Classic fairytale atmosphere

When the Sea Turned to Silver by Grace Lin
Quest to rescue grandmother
Inspired by Chinese folklore
Stunning illuminations and lush paintings
#ownvoices (Asian-American)

Tuesdays at the Castle by Jessica Day George
Living, transforming castle
Ruling family
Evil wizard
Rescue parents
Book 1 of 5

Into the Land of the Unicorns by Bruce Coville
Unicorns
Unicorns
Delightful non-unicorn characters
Unicorns
Book 1 of 4


πŸ‘» Ghosts

Ghost Squad by Claribel Ortega
Inspired by Dominican folklore
Family ghosts
Stormy graveyards
Cool grandma, cool cat
#ownvoices (Latinx)

The Ghost Collector by Allison Mills
Catches ghosts in her hair
Grandmother as caregiver
Working through grief
Not too heavy
#ownvoices (Ililiw [Cree])

A Sprinkle of Spirits by Anna Meriano
Family-run magical bakery
Five young brujas
Spirits shouldn’t be out
Book 2 of 3
#ownvoices (Biracial Latinx)

Just South of Home by Karen Strong
Small-town American south
Haunted abandoned church
Restless haints
Historical mystery
#ownvoices (Black)

Spirit Hunters by Ellen Oh
Haunted house
Angry ghost
Adorable little brother
Korean shamanism
#ownvoices (Korean-American)

A Properly Unhaunted Place by William Alexander
Ghosts are ordinary
But this town doesn’t them?
Appeasement librarians
Medieval fair
#ownvoices (Latinx)

The Swallow by Charis Cotter
1960s Toronto
Belonging and friendship
Family trouble
Who is the ghost?


πŸ’€ Creepy

Hoodoo by Ronald L. Smith
1930s Alabama
Hoodoo = folk magic
Can Hoodoo learn hoodoo?
A stranger on the hunt
#ownvoices (African-American)

The Nest by Kenneth Oppel
Wasp queen
Ill baby sibling
Yes or no?
Very creepy
Jon Klassen illustrated

The Jumbies by Tracey Baptiste
Inspired by Caribbean folklore
Beware the beautiful woman
Orange trees
Ancient magic
#ownvoices (Trinidadian)

Cuckoo Song by Frances Hardinge
1920s England – jazz!
Darkly atmospheric
Human world intersects with fae world
Nuanced adult characters

A Monster Calls by
Patrick Ness
Ill parent
Four tales
Tear-jerker
Not so creepy but has dark illustrations

Everlost by Neal Shusterman
Limbo after death (not too creepy, though)
Shadow world
Learn to haunt
Urban fantasy, of a sort
Book 1 of 3

Coraline by Neil Gaiman
Flipped house
Trapped children
Other Mother
Buttons
Children’s horror classic


🐲 Creatures

Malamander by Thomas Taylor
Entertaining protagonist
Legendary sea creature
Unusual seaside town
ASOUE vibes (with more competent adults)

Scary Stories for Foxes by Christian M. Heidicker
Anthropomorphized foxes
Yup, pretty scary at times
Dark illustrations
Watch out for Beatrix Potter
Interconnected short stories

Dragons in a Bag by Zetta Elliott
Brooklyn, NYC
Time travel
Deliver the baby dragons
Short and sweet
#ownvoices (Black)

The Sight by David Clement-Davies
Anthropomorphized wolves
Wolf gods
An ancient legend
Old world Transylvania
Lots of death


🧚🏼 Fairies

The Girl Who Raced Fairyland All the Way Home by Catherynne M. Valente
Portal fantasy
Character growth over series
Another great cast of characters
Satisfying conclusion
Book 5 of 5

Artemis Fowl

Artemis Fowl by Eoin Colfer
“Die Hard with fairies”
(Somehow, it works)
Rich criminal mastermind
(He’s 12)
Ireland

The Lost Flower Children by Janet Taylor Lisle
Summer with great-aunt
Garden in ruins
Find the teacups
Forgotten fairies?
One of the first books I bought with my allowance


🌍 Historical

The Book of Boy by Catherine Gilbert Murdock
14th century France
Pilgrimage
‘Collecting’ relics
Appearances not what they seem

Splendors and Glooms by Laura Amy Schlitz
Victorian London
Found family
Magic
Decades long rivalry
Puppeteering

The Inquisitor’s Tale by Adam Gidwitz
13th century France
Miracles and visions
Canterbury Tales-style
Wonderfully illuminated by Hatem Aly


Conclusion

And that’s it! Whoo, I think I spent more time on this post than any other. (I’ve just realized I didn’t include Inkspell?! Ah well. I should note that I purposefully excluded The Hobbit, as I count that as part of my Tolkien ‘fandom’ rather than my middle grade ‘fandom’.)

This list introduced you to a number of my personal favourites, but middle grade authors are really shining right now and there so many more excellent books that I still need to read. The best middle grade features characteristics I love and don’t always find in adult fiction: clear and simple yet evocative prose; characters who try to be better friends or family members; magic that does not have to cater to an adult’s sensibilities. If you haven’t read middle grade fantasy recently, I encourage you to give them a shot.

I’d like to conclude this post with a shout out to bloggers who review middle grade fantasy. Bloggers marked with πŸ“š primarily review middle grade (including fantasy), while bloggers marked with πŸ“™ occasionally review MG fantasy.

πŸ“š Alex @ Randomly Reading
πŸ“™ Alicia @ A Kernel of Nonsense
πŸ“š Brandy @ Random Musings of a Bibliophile
πŸ“š Brenda @ Log Cabin Library
πŸ“™ Briana and Krysta @ Pages Unbound
πŸ“š Charlotte @ Charlotte’s Library
πŸ“™ CW, Skye, and Joce @ The Quiet Pond
πŸ“™ Jessica @ Spooky KidLit
πŸ“š Katy @ A Library Mama
πŸ“š Mary @ Book Craic
πŸ“™ Nandini @ Novels and Nebulas
πŸ“š Rosemary @ Mom Read It

Do you read middle grade? Have you read any of these books? What are your favourite middle grade fantasies?

Jenna's signature

12 responses to “35 Middle Grade Fantasy Faves [Wyrd & Wonder]

  1. So many of my favorites are on this list!! Have you read Thisby Thestoop and the Wretched Scrattle? And thank you for the shout out.

  2. Meredith

    I enjoyed your post very much.
    The Nest was indeed creepy, but I couldn’t put it down.

    I recommend A Game of Fox & Squirrels, by Jenn Reese.

    • Thank-you! The Nest was a surprise read for me. I wasn’t expecting something so creepy from Kenneth Oppel. A Game of Fox & Squirrels is on my TBR – I’ve heard a lot of good things about it.

Leave a Reply